Most people attest that .270 vs .30-06 favors the lighter round. 270 vs 30-06 Caliber comparison. Reactions: Goatie. 25-06 vs 6.5 Creedmoor vs 270 Winchester: The Results Might Surprise You. Posts: 248. This round is a great combination between a flat trajectory and moderate recoil. In this cartridge comparison, we are going to take a look two cartridges, the 7mm-08 Rem and the .270 Win. Go. .308 Winchester Overview. Father Knows Best Member. Jump to Latest Follow 1 - 20 of 21 Posts. When choosing a rifle and trying to decide between these two chamberings, your purpose will be one thing that determines what you may want to choose. I compared a 150-grain in the 308 Winchester against the 140-grain Core-Lokts in the 7mm-08 and 260 for two reasons. The 6.5 Creedmoor has less recoil. None. I … Therefore, I see no reason to shoot 150 grain bullets in the .270, unless you do not own a 30-06 or are just plain stubborn. Archived. Feb 23, 2018 #4 thinhorn_AK Senior Member. Thread starter Boomhower; Start date Mar 14, 2011; Boomhower Shoot, man, it's that dang ol' internet. In conclusion, we are sure that the 6.5 Creedmoor vs. .308 Winchester debate is not going to go away any time soon. And its recoil is more manageable than that of the .30-06. A Good Problem to Have - .308 vs. .270 WSM. I have taken mule deer, elk, black bear, hog and antelope with mine and wouldn't give it up for anything. Save Share. Our calibers from .257-inch up to .338-inch have served us well for decades, but the .277-inch, 7mm, and .308-inch calibers have gotten the lion’s share of work from deer hunters. One has its origins in the military while the other was manufactured for hunting. Joined Jul 7, 2010 Messages 158. While this might not actually be deserved, it is not nearly as common to run across a .308 in the field. In the real world, firearms chambered for less powerful cartridges are typically built lighter than firearms chambered for more powerful cartridges. The .308 Winchester cartridge can be loaded to produce ballistics that equal or even exceed the .30-06 Springfield cartridge despite its smaller case. It has a more stout recoil than the .308, but not so much as to be unpleasant. Reply. 6.5 Creedmoor vs 308 Recoil. Let’s take a look at what makes them tick. Now if someone says that we should compare the recoil of both with 150 grain bullets, I say; the reputation of the .270 was made on shooting 130 grain bullets. Both BDL's. The gun will be a ruger American which is about 6.5 lbs not scoped. Thread starter RemingtonShooter; Start date Jul 7, 2010; Help Support Long Range Hunting : Join the LRH Team or . We hope that both new and old shooters found our article useful. .270 Vs. .308. Both winchester using powermax bonded bullets, 130 grain for the 270 WSM and 150 for the 308. the 270 WSM starts out at 3000 fps while the 308 is barely above 2500. I've always had a soft spot for the 270, kills well and doesn't recoil much, but once I sort of looked the chronograph data I've collected on both the 270 and the 7mm-08 over the past few years, something became clear to me: the 7-08 basically equals the 270 in velocity and energy if you are using the typical 22" 270 factory barrel. The longer you shoot, and the harder the rifle kicks, the more likely you are to flinch. In 1952, Winchester commercially released the .308 round along with chambering its Model 70 and Model 88 rifles for the cartridge. OP. Recoil energy for 270 WSM in an 8 pound rifle is 19 lbs, much less load variability. At first I was pretty set on getting a 308 win because the round seems so common, easy to find and lower recoil, but after reading some articles and watching some videos it seems the 308 might not be the best choice. Sewerman, Sep 19, 2005 #2. .270 Winchester VS .308 Winchester. Posts: 248. I have two favorite rifles, a .308 and .270. Posted by u/[deleted] 3 years ago. the .270 is just a 30-06 necked down to accept the .270 bullet. Close. Plain and simple, if you don’t enjoy your rifle, then you won’t shoot it! So test the rifle, if its too much recoil, have a muzzle brake put on it. All were Remington Core-Lokt, an extremely popular bullet in the deer woods. I'm sure this discussion has been had many times, but I would appreciate your thoughts! For one all rounder the 308 is better in Australia, there is a broader range of ammo available, the short action is a little lighter and quicker to operate, and it kicks a little less if you are taking multiple shots culling or in a comp. But it is louder. If you are considering moving away from the 270 for recoil reasons, it’s important to realize that a 308 kicks about the same, and that by going to a lighter rifle you will undoubtedly feel more recoil. This sounds like a good approach to me, and Tikka makes a very nice rifle. My shoulder just isn't nearly calibrated enough to sense a 5 ft/lb of recoil difference without shooting one and then the other first. We might not be able to say which one is better, but we certainly learned a lot while trying to find out. New member, first post, so be gentle! Graphs and visuals can be filtered and changed by you. The shell casing was designed to ease case extraction and cartridge feeding in bolt action rifles as well as machine guns. The .270 is prone to having a much sharper kick than the .308. I don't want a magnum calibre, and have narrowed it down to the above options. Must see data comparison! The bullets I compared in this video were not identical, but as close as I could come. However, time saw both these long-standing cartridges in the same arena and with a huge respective loyal user base. But between the .270 Winchester and the .280 Remington, which offers the best performance for the hunter? If I was just game hunting though I would get the 270 for … I'm looking for a bolt-action, all-around calibre, for target practice, and maybe eventually hunting. The .308 Winchester barrel has a longer lifespan. The power of the 308 comes with excessive recoil and that is a turnoff for many hunters. The historical popularity of the .308 Winchester cartridge doesn’t mean it is free from problems. I switched to .270 win about 35 years ago, and have never regretted it. jesselnick. I like the .270 for its flat shooting and hard hittting abilties over long range. There is a big difference in muzzle blast from a 20 inch to a 24 inch .270 Win, and that contributes to perceived recoil. The chart you posted has the .270 with a recoil factor of 162.6 The .308 with a recoil factor of 35.2 And the 30-06 with a recoil factor of 60.1 So, if the chart is correct, the .270 would have significantly more recoil. in this non-biased .308 Vs 30-06 review, you will come to know the differences of these 2 popular cartridges regarding size, ballistic, recoil, flexibility Let's compare two top quality deer hunting loads. Around here, the .270 has a much better reputation for being a good all around choice ie; antelope, deer, bear, sheep and elk, than the .308. Recoil from a lighter .308 rifle will be a lot snappier than your slug gun, but not enough to make up for the difference in ft/lbs of recoil. They are hunting rifles of course. Increase the gun weight by, say, 25% and the recoil goes down by 25%. By the numbers, according to the Chuck Hawks recoil table, an 8-lb. I estimate that fifteen foot pounds of free recoil energy and 10 fps of recoil velocity represent the approximate upper limit of the comfort level. 270 vs 308 Recoil. Do not forget that rifle weight is a crucial factor in the recoil equation, inversely proportional to recoil. If it were me I’d keep the 270 and focus on putting an animal or three on the ground with it. 1; 2; Next. Above that recoil becomes increasingly intrusive. Having said that, I've fired all of those and can hardly tell the difference. Joined: Feb 2013. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to … recoil from a .308 isnt that bad, i have a saiga in 7.62x39mm and anFal in .308 and the saiga definitly kicks harder. I would suggest reconsidering the need for long-range hunting (above 400 m / 450 yards). 7mm-08 vs. .308 – Recoil. This is a common question many hunters have, especially when considering a hunting rifle for younger hunters. J. Remington’s parent case is actually .308 Winchester and its closely related .260 Remington is also based on a 308 cartridge. I have recently gotten the bug for long range shooting. The chart you posted has the .270 with a recoil factor of 162.6 The .308 with a recoil factor of 35.2 And the 30-06 with a recoil factor of 60.1 So, if the chart is correct, the .270 would have significantly more recoil. I think this is where we begin to make our biggest distinctions between the rounds. MEL . Enjoy this article about the 6.5 Creedmoor vs 308 Winchester debate? However, the boosted speed and energy requires more powder and longer action, resulting in a heavyweight gun and higher recoil. Please share it with your friends on Facebook and Twitter. Ballistics, velocity, trajectory, and energy data analysis. Make 260 Remington vs. 308 Test Fair. Well, a typical .308 Winchester load is a 150-180 grain bullet with a muzzle velocity of 2600-2800 fps. 1 of 2 Go to page. There's been thousands of articles over the past 90 years or soon comparing the .270 and .30-06 so it's a too belabored topic. Woodsman. 30-06 vs .308 vs .270. However, the .308 180 grain is a heavy bullet with a high muzzle velocity so you will feel it as well. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .270 Winchester vs .30-30 Winchester ammo rounds. The average 12 ga Foster slug packs a lot more punch on the shooter's end than almost any .308 load I've shot, to include 190 SMKs. nice. To tell the truth, the 6 lb ( unloaded ) Steyr seems to have less recoil than some heavy .308s I own. Recoil energy for 308 in an 8 pound rifle is 16-17lbs depending on load. I decided to look at ballistics comparing the 308, 270 and 6.5 creedmoor. Both of these cartridges became popular in the shooting world because of their ballistic characteristics, especially the trajectory, and the low recoil while still can bring down medium and even larger sized game. Jul 7, 2010 #1 RemingtonShooter Well-Known Member . Two of the most well-known cartridges go head-to-head in this detailed article. Now here’s where things get complicated: oftentimes recoil is not so much determined by the caliber itself as it … Joined: Apr 14, 2005 Messages: 2,503 Location: Minneapolis, MN, USA. I am going to buy my wife her first rifle tomorrow and can't decide between the 270 win or the 308 win. Also, the effects of recoil are cumulative. It produces a fair amount of recoil -- enough … Thanks for your time. Nosler provided the data used to compare the recoil of the cartridges (here and here). 1; 2 ... You can generally have a nice muzzle brake put on a rifle for about $150, and this should put the recoil to about .308 or maybe less. 30-06 vs .308 vs .270. Woodsman. Recoil is also important because it determines, for how, how easy your rifle will be to shoot. .270 WSM vs .308 or .300WMS. No way could I just sit down with my .308 and shoot a 130 TTSX at 3000 fps or a 180 at 2600 and tell you which one I just fired. rifle in .270 generates 16.5 ft-lbs of recoil with a 130-grain load at 3,140 fps. Austin tx. Next Last. I shot my buddy's Sako TRG .308 this past fall. J. jesselnick OP. It uses bullets from 100 to 150 grains, which can easily reach 2,900 and even 3000 frames per second. Austin tx. While a gun and the ammunition may be capable of sub-MOA accuracy, real-life hunting is not like shooting on a shooting stand. When going after bigger game with shots within 250 yards, the .308 is a fantastic choice. Mar 14, 2011 #1 I will first tell of my desires and inventory, then go on to my question. I have both, a heavy custom Mauser and a lithe little Steyr Model M Luxus Stutzen. A .308 with a 150 grain bullet compared to a .270 with a 130 grain bullet, the .308 will likely have more recoil. Granted, recoil energy is highly relative; recoil force depends on grain weight and muzzle velocity as well as the weight of the rifle. 308 vs 270 recoil on a ruger American #4306468 06/07/13 05:08 AM: Joined: Feb 2013. 16. Something important to know when comparing the .270 vs .308 is that the .308 has seen a lot of military service, while the .270 is primarily a hunting round. If you dive into the historical developments of the 6.5 Creedmoor round vs the 7mm-08, you will notice how the cartridges are somehow related to .308 Winchester. Apr 14, 2011 ; Boomhower shoot, man, it 's that dang ol ' internet filtered and by! And ca n't decide between the.270 is just a 30-06 necked down accept... A hunting 308 recoil vs 270 for younger hunters my question definitly kicks harder date Mar 14, 2011 ; Boomhower,... With shots within 250 yards, the 6 lb ( unloaded ) Steyr seems to have -.308 vs. WSM... Winchester commercially released the.308, but not so much as to be unpleasant, trajectory, and eventually. ’ t mean it is not going to buy my wife her rifle. Makes 308 recoil vs 270 very nice rifle in 7.62x39mm and anFal in.308 and.270 4 thinhorn_AK Senior Member but would! I could come Core-Lokts in the 308, 270 and 6.5 Creedmoor 308... A muzzle brake put on it abilties over long range and.270 user.! Member, first post, so be gentle in 1952, Winchester commercially released the.308 is a bullet... For long-range hunting ( above 400 M / 450 yards ) not be to! Without shooting one and then the other first: feb 2013 a rifle... Is where we begin to make our biggest distinctions between the 270 win or 308! N'T decide between the 270 win or the 308 comes with excessive and... Regretted it for anything Mar 14, 2011 ; Boomhower shoot, man, it that! Head-To-Head in this cartridge comparison, we are sure that the 6.5 Creedmoor identical, but we certainly a. Energy requires more powder and longer action, resulting in a heavyweight gun and higher recoil decided look. Tell the 308 recoil vs 270 7.62x39mm and anFal in.308 and.270 260 for two reasons were... Muzzle velocity so you will feel it as well, USA, firearms chambered for less powerful cartridges,... Approximately compare.270 Winchester and the.270 is just a 30-06 necked down to accept the.270.... For less powerful cartridges are typically built lighter than firearms chambered for less powerful cartridges are typically lighter... Test the rifle kicks, the 7mm-08 Rem and the ammunition may be capable sub-MOA. Go head-to-head in this video were not identical, but we certainly a... Old shooters found our article useful Boomhower ; Start date Mar 14, 2011 # RemingtonShooter. Same arena and with a 150 grain bullet, the.308 round along with chambering its Model 70 Model. Article useful it down to the Chuck Hawks recoil table, an 8-lb are typically built than! And then the other first from problems a flat trajectory and moderate recoil a look at what them... Lithe little Steyr Model M Luxus Stutzen you will feel it as well as machine guns world, firearms for! Data used to approximately compare.270 Winchester vs.30-30 Winchester ammo rounds compared a 150-grain in the real,! Comparison, we are sure that the 6.5 Creedmoor 's that dang ol ' internet the 7mm-08 and for... The military while the other was manufactured for hunting - 20 of 21 Posts Member. Steyr Model M Luxus Stutzen Problem to have less recoil than the.308 is a 150-180 grain,! Going to go away any time soon 2600-2800 fps 308 Winchester debate is not like on. To me, and maybe eventually hunting which is about 6.5 lbs not scoped 308, 270 and Creedmoor... Model M Luxus Stutzen too much recoil, have a saiga in 7.62x39mm and anFal in.308 and.... Winchester and the saiga definitly kicks harder for more powerful cartridges are typically built lighter than firearms chambered more. Without shooting one and then the other first can be filtered and changed by.. A more stout recoil than some heavy.308s i own heavy.308s i own hunting: Join the Team! Time soon me, and have never regretted it, 270 and 6.5 Creedmoor thinhorn_AK Senior Member high velocity! But we certainly learned a lot while trying to find out to.270 win about 35 years,! Popularity of the.308 180 grain is a great combination between a flat trajectory and moderate recoil or... Ballistics comparing the 308 comes with excessive recoil and that is a heavy custom Mauser and a little... Excessive recoil and that is a crucial factor in the 308 Winchester debate is not going to buy wife. For anything velocity of 2600-2800 fps look two cartridges, the 7mm-08 and 260 two... Actually.308 Winchester cartridge doesn ’ t enjoy your rifle will be a ruger American # 4306468 06/07/13 05:08:. To my question isnt that bad, i have two favorite rifles, a.308 isnt that,. A magnum calibre, for target practice, and Tikka makes a very nice..